Skip to main content

This Should Be Good — a video podcast with Bishop Michael Martin and Andy Pfeiffer

This Should Be Good

A video podcast with Bishop Michael Martin and Andy Pfeiffer. Honest conversations for anyone still asking questions.

Bishop Michael Martin and Andy Pfeiffer, hosts of This Should Be Good
New episodes twice a month

The Show

A bishop and an ad guy walk into…

35 years ago, they were student and teacher. Today one owns an ad agency, the other is a bishop in the Catholic Church. Listen as they answer questions from the audience about life’s diverse topics; explore how we, as people, can be a little better; and discover which one has thinner skin.

For the skeptics, the believers, the just curious…

This should be good.

The Hosts

Different callings, same conversation.

Bishop Michael Martin, Bishop of Charlotte

Bishop Michael Martin

Bishop of Charlotte

Before becoming Bishop of Charlotte, Bishop Martin was a high school teacher and basketball coach—the kind who stuck around after practice to actually talk with, and listen to, you. Put simply, he cared.

He grew up in Baltimore, the only boy among four kids, and joined the Franciscan friars at seventeen. What’s a Franciscan? It means he’s chosen to follow in the teachings of St. Francis of Assisi and taken the vows of poverty, chastity, obedience, (and podcasting) … or keeping life simple. This shapes how he sees just about everything.

He was the kind of teacher and coach who stuck around after practice to actually talk with, and listen to, you. Put simply, he cared.

Bishop Martin spent years teaching and coaching at St. Francis High School (where his life clearly changed after meeting Andy) then moved on to Archbishop Curley, his old high school, eventually becoming principal. From there, he moved to North Carolina and spent twelve years leading the Catholic community at Duke. All that to say, he’s been fighting to get the most out of students (of all ages) for a very long time.

In 2024, Pope Francis named him the fifth Bishop of Charlotte.

Andy Pfeiffer, Founder, Arthur Elliott

Andy Pfeiffer

Founder, Arthur Elliott

As an eighth grader growing up in Buffalo, NY, Andy adamantly opposed going to an all-boys Catholic school. Enter Father Mike, the admissions director at St. Francis High School. Father Mike convinced Andy’s mother he would become a better person if he went to St. Francis. He was probably right, but to this day, Andy refuses to admit it.

After four years of being taught, coached, and mentored by Father Mike, the two formed a relationship that focused less on how Andy frequently skipped church, and more on how he should be using his God-given talent for good—despite being in advertising. In fact, this is why we have the podcast.

They formed a relationship focused less on how Andy skipped church, and more on how he should use his God-given talent for good.

Post-college, Andy moved to Charlotte. He started his career in advertising, eventually founding Arthur Elliott, a mid-sized ad agency that helps businesses “own their corner of the world.” He is a husband, a father of two amazing humans, and has been told by at least five people that he dresses well when he’s wearing navy. Andy has a big heart. He is sincere. And he believes in the currency of laughter.

The pope has no idea who Andy is.

Listen & Watch

Every episode, every platform, all in one place.

Ask Us

You have questions. We’d love to chat. Seriously, Ask anything…

We want to know what you want to know!
Send us questions and topics you’d like us to talk about.

We read every one. We won’t share your email.

Partners

Want to get involved?

  • Catholic Charities Diocese of Charlotte
  • SEARCH